| Sinestro | Mythic+ | S | S | S | S | Best DPS. |
| Superman | Mythic+ | S | S | S | S | Best tank, great damage. |
| Green Lantern | Mythic | S | S | S | S | Falls off due to no shields, 3rd skill useless. |
| Wonder Woman | Legendary | C | S | S | A | Still the best early-game F2P tank. |
| Deathstroke | Mythic+ | S | A+ | A+ | A+ | Insane at high stars, one-shots squishies. |
| The Joker | Mythic+ | S | A | A+ | A | Big buff, top CC DPS. |
| Scarecrow | Mythic+ | S | A | A | A | Less damage but tankier. |
| The Flash | Mythic | A+ | B | B | B | Frail, lost GL synergy. |
| Cyborg | Mythic | A+ | B | B | B | Reworked, still mid. |
| Red Robin | Mythic | B | B | B | B | Buffed, better once Nightwing is added. |
| Batman | Mythic | A | A+ | A+ | A | Solid, lacks early stars. |
| Poison Ivy | Mythic | A+ | A | A+ | A | Strong spiritual DPS support. |
| Zatanna | Mythic+ | A+ | A | A+ | A | Best support for spiritual DPS. |
| Harley Quinn | Mythic | A+ | A | A+ | A | Great tank & damage, lifesteal & regen. |
| Red Hood | Legendary | A | B | B | B | Good early DPS, lost anti-hero buff. |
| Mera | Legendary | A+ | A | A+ | A | Healer, lacks bulk due to gear change. |
| Black Adam | Legendary | A | A | A | A | Replaced by Sinestro but still solid early DPS. |
| Green Arrow | Legendary | A+ | A | A+ | A | Good early game, falls off late. |
| Shazam | Mythic | C | B | B | C | Protects Superman, solid at low stars. |
| Bane | Mythic | D | C | D | D | |
| Captain Cold | Legendary | D | C | D | D | Good in one TS stage. |
| Vixen | Legendary | C | C | C | C | Best new support, gives ATK boost. |
| Two-Face | Mythic | A+ | B | B | B | More damage, squishier. |
| Raven | Mythic | B | A | A+ | A | Great healer & support for spiritual DPS. |
| Killer Croc | Legendary | C | B | B | B | Solid but needs better teams. |
| Robin | Mythic | A | B | B- | B | |
| The Penguin | Mythic | C | C | C | C | Worse Two-Face, lacks damage. |
| Stargirl | Mythic | C | C | C | C | Useful in MM & Drowned CC bosses. |
| Aquaman | Mythic | B | A | B | B | Only useful in CC. |
| Batgirl | Mythic | B | B | B | B | |
| Deadshot | Mythic | C | D | D | D | Mid, some CC use. |
| Lex Luthor | Mythic | B | A | A | B | Decent damage but better as support. |
| Dr. Fate | Mythic | A | A | A | A | Good tank, better with JLD. |
| Catwoman | Legendary | D | D | D | D | Outperformed by all warriors. |
| Atom | Legendary | D | A+ | A+ | B | Huge buff, top-tier short-form content. |
| Black Canary | Mythic | D | D | C | D | Worst after Atom buffs. |